Category Archives: Antennas

Articles about Antennas, Feedlines, Towers and related equipment. Fixed, Portable and Mobile Antenna Articles are included.

My experience with Selecting and Installing a New Tower and New Antenna

Our New Home

It started over 2 years ago when my wife and I decided to downsize and chose a home for us to enjoy our final years.  I was also looking for a home that had a view and would allow a ham radio tower to be erected.

New Tower
Antenna and Tower with a View

My home and property

My house is at 810’ above sea level.   I have exceptional views South, and it extends both East and West.  I’m going to describe the home/tower exposure because it’s important for later.

To the North and East the tree line is about 100’ away and the ground slopes away about 40’ down North and a 60’ slopes down to the east.  To the West is nothing for 300 yards and slopes down over 160’.  To the south, there are 300 yards to the tree line which is below the line of sight and slopes down 160’.  Otherwise, we can see 40 miles south and 2 miles west and east.  To date, as a weather front comes through, we have experienced winds at around 45 MPH.  You can see from the photo that the view is spectacular.  I included a topo of where the house/tower is located, from this you can see the hilltop location.

Topo of Tower Location

Antenna Selection: Vertical

One of the first things I was told about selecting an antenna was to wait until you can afford a SteppIR antenna.  It made sense because you don’t have to worry about VSWR. The antenna will change the element length to match the frequency currently tuned to.  I have a Stepp BigIR Mark IV vertical which covers 40 Meters through 6 Meters. This antenna works great for FT8 also.  You just need to make sure you have lots of ground radials. I have 32 40’ radials.

Antenna Selection: Horizontal

I had a Mosley Classic 33, 10M, 15M 20M, tuner for voice, auto tuner had fits if I wanted to do FT8.  I was looking for something that would provide good results for low sun cycle propagation.  That meant wanting 20M and 40M and the other bands would be nice when the sun cycles improved.  I focused on 3 elements vs 4 elements.  So, I settled on the SteppIR DB18, because I could not justify a $2000 increase for an antenna that gave less than 2dB more gain.  Also, this antenna allows me to flip the antenna 180 in like 2 seconds, make the director the reflector and the reflector the director

  • Antenna: SteppIR DB18 7MHz to 50MHz
    • 1 sqft wind load
    • 96 lbs
    • SDA2000
  • Rotator: Alfa Spid Big RAK
    • 1’ wind load, 3,240 in-lbs turning torque, 14,000 lbs braking torque
    • 16 lbs, 2” top to 2.6” bottom.
    • Hold >700 lbs.
  • Mast: ¼” thick walls, 17’ long, 2” at the base and 1 ½” at the top. 5-foot wind load buried 4 feet into the tower

Town Requirements

Some towns only allow amateur radio towers to be 50’ while other towns allow 70’.  Antrim initially had 70’ for amateur radio and if you wanted taller than that you had to follow the commercial tower requirements.  It is now whatever the FCC / State requires.  When I filed for the permit the inspector stated that a building permit is not required for amateur radio towers, but he did look at the request to ensure there was no safety issues, ie., could the tower fall on a neighbor’s house, public roadway, etc. and that I was more than 50’ from the roadway and 25’ to the property line. I had also submitted a copy of my Amateur Radio License, which he thanked me for and requested that I submit my renewal when I do my 10 year renewal.  He then filed all of it into the town records.

It doesn’t hurt to talk to your neighbors to ensure that they will not be upset at you for putting up this (non-hams) ugly tower.  I did this and we agreed that if I put the tower towards the front of my garage it would not be as visible to him.

My Tower Requirements

To start with you have to have a wish list in mind.  Mine was as follows:

  • DIY (do it yourself) Install
  • No climbing
  • Fold Over at the base
  • Would be nice to be able to hang an 80m inverted Vee (65’)

Tower Selection

The easiest way was to start looking at the Rohn catalog.  They have a section in front to get you started.  They start with understanding TIA-222 revision G.  It goes through Classification of the antenna structure, HAM’s will always be Class I.  Next is the EPA (Effective Projected Area) or area (size) of your antenna, don’t forget the mast and the rotor.   Next is what is your exposure, folks in the flatlands of Ohio(?) will be exposure C, here in New Hampshire where we have mostly 100’ trees around most homes and will be Exposure B.  Anyone living along the coast fits the last exposure D.  The next category is what snagged me.  Topographic category, remember the section above where I pointed out the terrain of my house.  I got snagged as a category 3 site, at the top of a hill which means you must multiply the wind load by 2.3.  Damn, that’s 10.1 + 1 + 1.5 = 12.6 * 2.3 = 28.98.  That’s a huge value.

So now I set out to search for an antenna company to meet my wish list.  Remember, I’m not interested in climbing a tower.  There are lots of towers out there, but I needed something with the ability to handle 29 EPA (that’s TIA-222 talk for wind load).  ROHN towers did not meet my wish list of no climbing towers.  Universal towers have an aluminum tower rated for 35 sqft at 110 MPH winds. Next was Heights Towers, they had aluminum towers rated by the exposure that would meet the requirements.  I love the features that they offer and the fold-over kit.  But not the cost.  I’m retired and don’t make a lot of money, so I opted for the Universals tower.  When looking at these towers don’t forget the cost to ship it to you.  There is a big difference shipping from Florida to NH vs Michigan to NH (more than double).

Tower Height

I read in QST “The DR Is In” article where someone was asking how high does a Yagi antenna needs to be?  His reply was a Yagi only needs to be 43 feet off the ground.  I also know that angle is related to the topology of where the tower is installed.  Therefore my 40-foot tower is great for my topology.

The base for a Standalone Tower

Tower Installation

Did you know that digging a hole for a self-supporting tower is a really BIG HOLE.  5 feet by 5 feet by 6 feet deep?  It took me 2 weeks of digging a couple of hours per day to dig the hole and I move the dirt away.  The last foot was this stone and stone dust mixture.  I only got down a couple of inches per day.  Lessons Learned don’t wait to make the bottom of the hole 5’ by 5’, because every shovel full is going up over 6’.  Why not a backhoe?  They don’t want the dirt disturbed around the hole.  Besides I wanted to DIY.  It takes 6 cubic yards of cement to fill a 5’ x 5’ x 6’ deep hole. I waited almost 2 weeks to raise the tower/antenna.  The concrete was nice and hard.  I actually built the antenna during the curing time.

Another lesson learned, concrete in the center will shrink, next tower (HaHa) don’t level it, instead have the center higher than the sides and exaggerate it.

New Tower
Raising the tower.

Tower Raising

I had some older tower parts and I thought I’d use them as a fulcrum.  On the back of the truck is a hand winch.  Went high enough on the tower (halfway to the top of the actual tower) to anchor onto the back 2 legs.  The fulcrum didn’t respond well so I called a safety assessment time out.  We lowered and only went up about 12’ and only used a 10’ section of the tower.  This ended up working much better but the winching was much harder.  I’d like to redesign the fulcrum and swap out the hand winch with a power winch.

Cable Selection

I choose to use LMR-900 to run from the entry point to the top of the tower.  Worked out to be 110’.    The top of the tower to the antenna is 10 feet of LMR400, from the house entry point to the back of the radio is 15’ of LMR400.

Did you ever want to know how much power you are radiating in the direction of your wonderful Yagi? First, you must determine the power you’re going to lose through the cable at the frequency you’re transmitting at.  Next subtract the cable loss from the power out of your transmitter, say 100 watts. Then look up your antenna gain, convert dBi to dB and multiply that by how much power you are providing the antenna at that frequency.  The results will be how much transmit power you are sending in a direction.  This whole exercise is based on dB and Transmit Power or dB loss/gain.  I had to convert things back and forth to get the right power from dB gain.

Antenna Power Out by Frequency

It’s the little details that are missed sometimes.  Making drip loops to ensure that water doesn’t run down your cable and right into your connector or control box.  Have enough cable for the rotor to turn 360 degrees.  Have enough cable to fold down the tower.New Tower

Tower Completion

I grounded the tower on all three legs.  I used 4 gauge bare solid copper wire from the tower leg to ground rods, 4’ from the tower legs.  I wanted to run the RF cable down the center of the tower.  It made sense that lightning would travel on skin effect (tower legs) and not on the RF/control cables to the ground.  I did not have a good enough method to hold the cable suspended in the center of the tower.  A failure of my ingenuity.

Also, at the entry point into the house, there is a ground rod that I have an RF lightning arrester attached to.  There are no lightning arrestors for the control cables.  This ground rod is also grounded to the point of entry ground rod and is the ground point for all of my radios and support equipment.

At the very top of the tower, I have a wind gage (anemometer) but it doesn’t give me the wind direction.  It’s a very simple device.  It uses a bicycle reader and the anemometer at the top.  Just counts revolutions, it gives you current, average and MAX speed.  It was all I needed, I’ve tried others and they didn’t last very long or did not give an accurate wind speed.

Now the SteppIR doesn’t help me for VHF/UHF and you probably asking why didn’t I put a VHF/UHF antenna on top of the tower.  I have a CREATE Log periodic in my attic on a rotor.  It is able to do a full circle in less than 60 inches.  My cable run is very short, so power loss is kept minimal.   Covers 50 to 1,300Mhz and has 10dBi gain.  I have this going to an antenna switch to go to multiple radios.

So far, I’m getting great reception in Europe.  Had contacts with Japan, South Africa and have been hearing Australia and Indonesia.  One of the reasons I love FT8 is it labels the contact’s country of origin.  Just wait as the sun cycle improves, so will my contact log.

The next project is to complete a wiring diagram of my shack.  I’d like to be able to visually know how everything is wired together.

Hope this helps you with your design and planning process for your dream tower.

It would be nice if there was an Elmer antenna and tower board to submit your ideas to get feedback.

73,

Brian, W1XMM

QRP Antenna Connectors: BNC or RCA?

Which is best for QRP Antenna Connectors: BNC or RCA? I’ve seen both on the web, so I’m trying to decide which connector to use for a QRP antenna.  Maybe you can help me out: Which is the “best” (most common, most useful, works best) for a QRP Antenna Connector: BNC (which stands for “Bayonet Neill-Concelman” according to Wikipedia) or RCA “phono” connectors (they were used for connecting a turntable to an audio amplifier for something like a half a century)?

QRP Antenna Connectors - 50 Ω Female BNC Connectors (Photo by W1AKI)
50 Ω Female BNC Connectors (Photo by W1AKI)

BNC connectors cost more but won’t come loose.  RF cables with BNC connectors seem to be more available.  What I didn’t realize until recently is that they come in both 75 Ω and 50 Ω types.  My picture above seems to be of the 50 Ω type.  Wikipedia has a side-by-side picture comparing the two types.  The commercial version of the Buddipole uses them.

QRP Antenna Connectors - Female RCA Connectors (Photo by W1AKI)
Female RCA Connectors (Photo by W1AKI)

RCA connectors are inexpensive but can become unplugged.  This can be an annoyance if you lose your connection when someone trips over the cable, or it can be a feature in that the antenna won’t get pulled over when someone trips over the cable

(Of course, any cables that are up over the ground, or any guy lines, should be marked with flagging tape — available from any hardware store — to prevent someone from tripping.)

Comments?  Votes?

Thank you.

Aron, W1AKI

2 Meter Vertical Yagi for Better VHF Performance

Some Issues with 2 meters VHF

I have a VHF radio in my car with a mag-mount antenna. One of the things I like to do is join in the Nashua Area Radio Society’s Weekly Repeater Net. I enjoy it so much that I volunteer to be in the Net Control rotation. When it is my turn, I need to be sure I can reliably reach the repeater and there were a few times when my mobile setup let me down.

Yaesu FTM-3200D
Yaesu FTM-3200D

I recently updated my shack to include a Yaesu FTM-3200D 2-meter radio that has up to 65 Watts output on 2 meters.

Diamond X200A Dual Band VHF/UHF Antenna
Diamond X200A Dual Band VHF/UHF Antenna

I paired that with a Diamond X200A Dual Band VHF/UHF Antenna and things improved a bit, but there were still a few times when I was scheduled to be Net Control that I could not reliably connect to the repeater.    I did some research and here is what I learned.

Distance and Line of Sight Calculator to Repeater
Distance and Line of Sight Calculator to Repeater

VHF, especially in the FM mode is mainly a line of sight band.  There are many propagation modes that go way beyond the line of sight, such as Sporadic-e, Tropospheric ducting, Auroral propagation, Meteor scatter, and Earth-Moon-Earth (EME), but they are not relevant to this discussion of connecting to a repeater.  The map above shows the approximate location of the repeater and my QTH in Tewksbury.  I looked up the height of the repeater antenna and my QTH and came up with a difference between them to help calculate the distance to the horizon from one point to the other.  Here is the link to the calculator in the blue box:  http://www.ringbell.co.uk/info/hdist.htm  Line of sight, as it applies to radio in this situation extends a bit beyond what the optical line of sight maybe, and that describes perfectly the situation shown above.  The repeater appears to be located about 10% beyond the optical line of sight from my QTH.

What can I do about it?

Most of the time, I can connect to the repeater.  Unfortunately, I cannot predict whether or not I will be able to connect.  The first thing I thought I could try was to raise the antenna at my QTH to extend the view over the horizon.  I checked on the LOS calculator and found that adding 10 feet to my antenna mast would only get me out to 21.2 miles or a .3-mile gain.  This approach would quickly reach the point of diminishing returns, so I needed another solution.  The next thing I thought about was improving the antenna.  2-meter yagi beam antennas are very reasonably priced, and I found the Diamond A144S10 Base Station Yagi Beam Antenna for under $95.00.  It has 11.6 dBi gain, so should work well.

A144S10 Base Station Yagi Beam - 2 meter yagi
A144S10 Base Station Yagi Beam

Any antenna project will include more than the price of the antenna but by using some parts I already had on hand and adding an inexpensive TV rotator, I was able to install the antenna at a reasonable cost.

Building the 2 Meter Yagi Antenna

Antenna Unboxed - 2m Yagi
Antenna Unboxed

The antenna comes in a small box with many of the parts pre-assembled.

Beginning the Assembly - 2 meter Yagi
Beginning the Assembly

I twisted the elements of one section into position and tightened the wing nuts to hold them in place.

After repeating the process with the other elements and assembling the pieces I moved on to install the horizontal bracket on a piece of chain link top rail I used for the mast.

Stand-off Mounting Bracket
Stand-off Mounting Bracket

The stand-off bracket serves two functions.  First, it attaches the antenna to the mast in a vertical orientation and second, it moves the antenna away from the mast so that there is no interaction between the metal mast and the antenna elements.

Completed Antenna Staged on Mast - 2 meter Yagi
Completed Antenna Staged on Mast

Here is the antenna staged without the rotator, prior to installation on the roof.

Preparing to install the antenna on the roof

It is a good idea to pre-wire the antenna rotator and calibrate it before going up on the roof.  The Hy-Gain AR-500 Rotator is easy to configure.

Hy-Gain AR-500 Rotator
Hy-Gain AR-500 Rotator

I installed the tripod on the roof taking care to place the lag bolts into the rafters and waterproof them thoroughly.  Importantly, I used the level and the top rail to ensure that it would be vertical prior to mounting it to the roof.

Tripod Base Mount
Tripod Base Mount
Antenna, Mast Sections and Rotator Assembled - 2 Meter Yagi
Antenna, Mast Sections, and Rotator Assembled

Assemble the Antenna, Mast, and Rotator.

Attach Wires, Coax and Guy Lines - 2 Meter Yagi
Attach Wires, Coax, and Guy Lines

Next, attach all wires, coax, and guy lines while the antenna is in reach.

Install the 2 Meter Yagi antenna in the roof mount tripod

Lifting the Completed Antenna Assembly - 2 meter Yagi
Lifting the Completed Antenna Assembly

Lifting the completed assembly to mount it in the tripod.

I lined up the whole assembly and carefully lifted it into the tripod mount.  If I ever do this again, I will have a helper!

3 Antennas Over the House - 2 meter Yagi
3 Antennas Over the House
HF and VHF Antennas
HF and VHF Antennas

The Hex Beam is 33 feet up.  The new A144S10 10 element 2 meter Yagi is around 28 feet and the Diamond X200A is around 20 feet high at the feed point.

The results are in

Finally, I made arrangements with Fred, AB1OC to do some testing later that afternoon.  I oriented the antenna to the compass accurately and looked up the heading to the repeater.  Fred helped me with adjusting my mic gain and power output to make sure the radio was working properly.  After a few tweaks, we were both happy with the results. I hosted the Nashua Area Radio Society’s Weekly Repeater Net that night, which turned out to be a success.  I am looking forward to exploring the capabilities of this new antenna.

Jon, AC1EV

Radio Amateurs Developing Skills Worldwide